Skip to main content
Insights
Diagnosis and auditAnswer 8 min read

How do you know if your agency is doing a good job?

Run seven checks in an afternoon: admin access, leads matched to your CRM, a written baseline, ten leads traced to sale. No agency help needed.

Mark BodnarCEO | Growth product manager, Berlitz 5 November 2026
On this page (7)
  1. Why your own checks beat the agency's report
  2. What are the seven checks?
  3. How we would run the afternoon
  4. What does it cost to check?
  5. Who is to blame when a check fails?
  6. Questions people ask
  7. Where this is weak

You know your agency is doing a good job when its numbers hold up to checks you run without it. Seven checks cover it, from account ownership to ten leads traced to a sale. They take one afternoon, cheap next to a median retainer of about €9K a month in Canada, the UK, Western Europe and the US.

Why your own checks beat the agency's report

Most agency reports are accurate about what they measure. The problem is what they choose to measure: impressions, clicks, cost per click, sessions. Those numbers describe activity. Whether the activity paid for itself sits in your CRM and your bank account, which the agency usually cannot see.

Agencies have a fair reply. Some work, brand or new search content in its first months, does not show up cleanly in a quarter. That is true, and I come back to it at the end. But "hard to measure" should cover a small share of the fee, not most of it.

Two ways to judge the same month

What the report tells you

Spend, reach, clicks, cost per click, a chart that goes up. Chosen and framed by the people being paid.

What you can check yourself

Who owns the accounts, whether their lead count matches your CRM, and what those leads were worth once sales touched them.

Same data underneath. The right column needs no one's permission.

An agency is doing a good job when its numbers survive checks it does not control.

What are the seven checks?

Each one takes between ten minutes and an hour. None needs the agency to send you anything.

  1. Log in as admin to everything. Ad accounts, analytics, tag manager, the CMS, the email platform. They should sit under your company, with the agency added as a user you can remove. If the agency owns the account and you are the guest, fix that before you judge anything else.
  2. Match one month of leads. Take the lead count from last month's report and count the same month in your CRM. Then open the conversion settings in the ad account and read what counts as a lead. Counts grow without anyone lying: a newsletter signup or brochure download tagged as a conversion, the same person filling in the form twice, spam the form lets through. A small gap is normal. A gap nobody can explain means the report measures something other than your business.
  3. Find the baseline. Look for the numbers written down before the work began. No baseline means nobody can say the agency moved anything, including the agency.
  4. Follow ten leads to the end. Pick ten from last quarter at random and ask sales what happened to each one. On a Berlitz UK offer campaign we ran, 21% of leads became paid enrolments. That is the kind of number to ask for: what happened after the form, not how many forms.
  5. Divide the fee by the result. Add the agency fee to media spend, then divide by the closed sales or qualified leads from check four. Most reports show cost per lead on media alone, which leaves out the most predictable line on the invoice.
  6. Put the last three invoices beside what is live. For every billed item, find the page, the campaign or the email. From what we have seen, work that was billed and never shipped is a common leak, and it is rarely bad faith.
  7. Search your inbox for "stop". Find one time in the last six months the agency told you not to spend on something. If there is none, ask yourself why.

A lead in the report is whatever the conversion tag fires on, so read the tag before you trust the count.

How we would run the afternoon

Order matters, because the early checks decide whether the later ones are possible. Without access you cannot reconcile. Without reconciliation, cost per sale is a guess.

One afternoon, in this order

01AccessAdmin logins in your company's name. List anything you cannot open.
02ReconcileTheir lead count against your CRM for one month, what the conversion tag counts, and the written baseline if it exists.
03TraceTen leads followed to a sale or a no, then fee plus media divided by the outcome.
04ReadInvoices against live work, and the inbox search for a recommendation to stop.
Write the results in one document so you can run the same checks next quarter and compare.

Then score each check plainly: pass, fail, or could not check. A single fail is a conversation with the agency. A "could not check" means the measurement is missing, and that is true whether the agency is good or not.

If three or more checks come back as could not check, I would fix measurement before judging the agency at all.

What does it cost to check?

Mostly your time: an afternoon from a marketing lead who already has the logins. Compare that with the fee being judged. In Canada, the UK, Western Europe and the US the median full-service retainer is about €9K a month, by our own benchmark. Without the checks, the renewal of that fee gets decided on the agency's own report.

The cost rises when the early checks fail. If you cannot get admin access, or the CRM is too messy to count leads, someone has to fix the setup before any judgement is possible. That work is often billed at agency rates, and the buyer-market median is about €150 an hour. I still think it is worth paying for, because the other option is renewing a contract with no way to read the result.

If you want a second pair of eyes, we run a free growth audit that covers the same ground. We are an agency and we would like your business, so read that as disclosure. You do not need us, or anyone, to run the seven checks above.

The checks cost an afternoon when your setup is clean, and the price of fixing the setup when it is not.

Who is to blame when a check fails?

Not always the agency. Before you read a fail as a verdict, sort it by owner.

Access and reconciliation belong to the agency. If they built your ad account under their own name, or their lead count has no link to yours, that is on them. The baseline is shared: an agency should insist on one, but it often goes missing because the client never sent the numbers. Lead follow-up is yours. If sales never mark leads as won or lost, check four fails and no agency can fix it. Unshipped work is often yours too, waiting in an approval queue on your side.

Two fails that sit with your sales team call for a different meeting from two that sit with the agency.

Write the owner next to every fail before you take it to the agency.

Questions people ask

How long should I give a new agency before judging results?

Judge access and reporting from the first week, since owning your accounts and matching lead counts do not depend on results. Judge outcomes after at least one full sales cycle. For paid search that is often a quarter. For search content or brand work it is longer, and the agency should say up front when it expects the first number to move.

Who should own the Google Ads and analytics accounts?

You should. The ad accounts, analytics property, tag manager and CMS should sit under your company, with the agency added as a user you can remove. If the agency owns them, you lose the history when the contract ends and you cannot check their reporting while it runs. Most agencies will transfer ownership if asked, so ask before anything else.

Is it normal for agency lead numbers to differ from my CRM?

A small gap is normal. Spam submissions, duplicates, newsletter signups tagged as conversions and different attribution windows all produce one. What is not normal is a gap nobody can explain, or one that only ever runs in the agency's favour. Ask the agency to walk you through one month line by line, including what its conversion tag counts as a lead.

What should a good agency report show?

The things most reports leave out: the baseline next to the current number, a lead count that matches your CRM, cost per sale with the agency fee included, and what the agency recommended you stop doing and why. Clicks and reach can stay in an appendix. They help explain the result, but they are not the result.

Should I tell my agency I am running these checks?

Yes. Nothing in the checks needs their help, but explaining a gap usually does. Tell them which checks you are running, then give them a week to answer each fail in writing. An agency that hears about a failed check for the first time at renewal has no chance to fix it, and you lose an explanation that might change your view.

Where this is weak

These checks favour work with a form at the end. Paid search and lead generation pass or fail clearly. Brand work, PR and new search content show up slowly, and in a long B2B sales cycle ten leads from last quarter may not have closed yet, so check four will look worse than the work is. In the first months of a contract there is too little data for checks four and five to mean much. Low lead volume makes everything noisy: ten leads from a quiet quarter can swing either way. And the checks tell you whether you can trust the numbers, not whether another agency would beat them. For that you need a second opinion or a small paid trial, which costs more than an afternoon.

Sources

  1. Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, federalregister.gov, Aug 2024

Filed underDiagnosis and auditAgency performance reviewMarketing auditLead qualityAgency contracts

Put it to work

The service behind this, and where we did it

The service

CRM & marketing automation

Salesforce, HubSpot, ActiveCampaign or your stack: scoring, routing, nurture flows and clean data. We work in the platform you have, or help you choose one, and never resell it.

Where does your own site stand? The free audit checks search visibility, AI citations and page speed.

Free growth audit
How do you know if your agency is doing a good job?